THE EDITORIAL TEST
A good zero on the evidence question is more useful than a misleading 10/10 that gets the pitch rejected.
1. Reader value — score 0, 1 or 2
Can you state who outside the company benefits from the finding? Zero means only the vendor cares; one means the audience is plausible; two means the reader has a concrete decision or risk to understand.
2. Evidence and independence — score 0, 1 or 2
Can the source, date, sample and limitations be inspected? Zero means the claim cannot be substantiated; one means partial proof exists; two means a qualified reviewer can reproduce or audit it. A zero here blocks publication regardless of the total.
3. Access, timing and fit — score each 0, 1 or 2
Can a spokesperson answer critical follow-ups? Is the angle timely for a named beat? Are customer permissions and confidentiality clear? Score the three separately. A high combined score signals readiness to pitch—not a promise of acceptance.
ILLUSTRATIVE STORY BRIEF — NOT A CLIENT CASE
What this might look like
An enterprise vendor has a credible migration lesson and approved architect, but no documented denominator for a claimed 40% improvement. Mark evidence 0 and correct the claim instead of pitching the headline.
What score means 'ready'?
Use judgment rather than an automatic threshold. The evidence section must be defensible; even an otherwise high-scoring story may be wrong for the selected journalist.
Watch out: Treating the worksheet as an automated PR guarantee.