THE EDITORIAL TEST
Ask to see a complete chain from original evidence to published article—not only a collage of headlines.
Ask for similar buying problems, not just similar industries
A firm that understands developer adoption may differ from one specializing in investor announcements. Ask who will interview the engineer, which trade beats matter, and what the first research question would be for your actual customer.
Inspect the provenance of claimed coverage
Select several examples and confirm the publisher URL, editorial independence, relevance, client role, dates and permissions. Check whether a placement was a guest post, paid sponsorship, press release syndication or independent reporting.
Review the working rules
Agree account ownership, expert approval, confidentiality, journalist follow-up, output definitions, replacement remedies and how bad news is reported. A thoughtful agency should be comfortable saying a proposed finding is not yet ready to pitch.
ILLUSTRATIVE STORY BRIEF — NOT A CLIENT CASE
What this might look like
During a tender, ask two agencies how they would turn an unremarkable integration release into a useful industry investigation. The stronger answer will probably describe questions and evidence gaps before naming publications.
What should a 30-minute selection call accomplish?
It should identify the buyer problem, source readiness, priority markets, editorial risks and the likely scope of a commercial pilot.
Watch out: Unlimited coverage promises without a demonstrated editorial process.