THE EDITORIAL TEST

The right scope starts with the work needed to produce a defensible story, not an arbitrary promise of media hits.

01 /

Separate fixed work from variable effort

Research design, interviews, editing, expert review and reporting are largely controllable. Whether a publication accepts a pitch is not. Ask a proposed agency to explain how it budgets the former and handles the uncertainty of the latter.

02 /

Check what the retainer really includes

Clarify jurisdictions, number of campaigns, original data production, spokesperson preparation, editorial outreach, revision rounds, paid third-party costs and ownership of the research asset. A media database license should not be confused with a paid placement.

03 /

Ask about the stop/go criteria

A well-run pilot should have decision dates: was the approved research compelling, did any credible reporters engage, did the coverage reach relevant buyers, and should the next study be repeated or abandoned? Make commercial outcomes and margins visible.

ILLUSTRATIVE STORY BRIEF — NOT A CLIENT CASE

What this might look like

A 90-day pilot could include one independently reviewable study, approved spokespeople, an outreach period and a placement-quality report. The fee should be quoted only after scope and resource needs are verified.

Is pay-per-link pricing always better?

No. It can align incentives but also encourage low-quality inventory or excessive delivery risk. Define editorial independence, eligible outcomes and exclusions before comparing prices.

Watch out: The proposal guarantees rankings or hides the actual origin of placements.